I was planning on doing this and putting my slips of paper in a mason jar, but turns out my mom couldn't part with any. I did; however, have this little box she had given me years ago that I never used. So I used that instead.
It took me quite a bit, because I meticulously wrote down every single book I had on my to-read shelf on my good reads profile. 102 books. I have a hundred and two books in this little box. I think I put some series in here too, so I think I can bend the rules if I pick up book 3 in a trilogy, or something similar.
I love creative stuff like this, so I recommend it to any reader that needs to find a different way to decide what they want to read.
Happy Reads Everyone!